Author: marie

How the University of Rwanda and VVOB chose their blend of in-person and remote CPD

The University of Rwanda – College of Education (URCE), in partnership with VVOB – education for development, has been organising accredited Continuous Professional Development (CPD) programmes for school leaders and secondary teachers since 2018. These programmes were initially being offered through in-person sessions. Accelerated by the COVID-19 pandemic, a quick shift to remote learning took place. Building on the lessons learnt from remote CPD delivery, in 2022, the development task-team consisting of staff from URCE and VVOB, re-designed the blended delivery approach of the CPD programmes, responding to the following question: 

Which delivery approach is the best fit to achieve our learning outcomes?

The underpinning pedagogy of the programmes is summarised in the following principles: competence-based learning, a sense of community and critical reflection. 

Participants are requested to actively try-out, practise, share and reflect on course content. Together with the intended learning outcomes and available course content, the development task team considered these course principles in the delivery of the CPDs. Online learning is used to help participants explore new content, to gain understanding via interactive activities, and to start reflecting and linking this knowledge to the participants’ own context. The in-person sessions are intended for activities that help apply the content at a deeper level. These sessions also provide an opportunity to close learning gaps identified by analysing the participants’ online learning progress, to help participants to take the next step in their learning via reflection, peer learning and application, practise skills via exercises and role play, and to strengthen a sense of community.

Each CPD starts with an in-person orientation session to introduce participants to the purpose and delivery approach of the programme. Moreover, such in-person orientation sessions offer the opportunity to build relationships.

Using bridging activities to create a staggered learning approach | by VVOB

VVOB – education for development supports the University of Rwanda – College of Education (UR-CE) and Rwanda Basic Education Board (REB) to organise accredited blended CPD programmes for school leaders and school-based mentors. 

The delivery method of these programmes is based on a thoughtful fusion of remote and in-person learning activities connected by bridging activities. This combination allows for a staggered learning approach based on the flipped classroom model. Each CPD programme starts with an in-person orientation session to introduce participants to the purpose and delivery approach of the programme. 

Moreover, such in-person orientation sessions offer the opportunity to build relationships. After this introductory in-person session, participants engage in interactive online course content. In this component, participants gain knowledge and understanding of the topics of the CPD programme. 

At the end of an online module, bridging activities are introduced to offer participants the opportunity to start reflecting on the content of the module and to translate the content to their work practice. After the online component of the module, participants go to an in-person module session to practise the content with their peers and to deepen their learning. 

At the end of a module, participants complete assignments in which they analyse the content and apply it to their work practice. Twice during the programme, a support visit is organised to participants’ work practice (school). The first visit is a coaching and support visit. The second visit is organised towards the end of the programme to assess the application of skills acquired. 

An example of a staggered approach using bridging activities is the development of a CPD plan for the school. In Rwanda, school-based mentors have the responsibility for guiding CPD of teachers in the school, by creating a school CPD plan. In the CPD programme, school-based mentors learn to develop an effective CPD plan for their school. They do this step by step over each building block of the blended CPD programme:

  • Online module: school-based mentors learn how to identify and assess teachers’ professional development needs.
  • Bridging activity: school-based mentors guide four teachers in their school to complete the CPD needs assessment tool.
  • In-person session: together with their peers, school-based mentors build a school CPD plan based on the needs of four teachers in their school.
  • Assignment: school-based mentors submit a full CPD plan for their school.

In short, the blended design of these CPD programmes allows scaffolding at each step in the learning of participants. 

Example of a staggered learning approach to blended CPD design

Preparing facilitators to transfer their teaching to an online modality by Plan International – Jordan

In this project from Plan International, facilitators of an existing project had to quickly adapt their teaching approach and curriculum to suit remote learning due to the COVID-19 crisis. In total, 50 to 60 facilitators of informal and non-formal programmes were targeted, who were training adolescents and youth aged 12 to 24 years old. 

To support these facilitators with the switch to remote facilitation, a phased approached was used, informed by contextual factors:

  • An emergency phase: daily intensive communication with facilitators to provide immediate support using Zoom and Teams for synchronous training and WhatsApp for both synchronous and asynchronous training.
  • A less intensive phase: a more structured modality during which facilitators meet synchronously 3 times/week, with a shift towards self-study by providing guides and manuals. 
  • A blended (in-person/remote) phase: facilitators meet once a week in-person, combined with asynchronous learning.

During these three phases, education specialists from Plan International set up a WhatsApp group with facilitators to:

  • Create a sense of presence to support facilitators in the shift to remote facilitation.
  • Give facilitators ample opportunities to ask questions about using digital tools.
  • Build rapport and motivation with facilitators. 
  • Provide both asynchronous and synchronous support to facilitators to cater for facilitators with weak connectivity.

Identifying blended CPD delivery improvement actions by piloting a play-based teaching project | by BRAC IED

BRAC Institute of Educational Development (BRAC IED) has implemented the “Champion Teachers” initiative that empowers teachers by enhancing their knowledge and skills in play pedagogy. 

The Champion Teachers initiative used a blended design. A fully in-person modality would have been too expensive and would not have been feasible, as some schools are located in remote regions. 

The training is centred around four broad areas: play and play pedagogy; well-being and teacher-student relationship; utilisation of available space and materials to apply play pedagogy in school compounds; and play-based lesson plan. Teachers are equipped with the required skills and knowledge to integrate play-based pedagogy in lessons and facilitate active participation by students. 

25 teachers were selected for the piloting of the intervention. A 5-day virtual training session was designed for the teachers to ensure the effectiveness and successful implementation of the intervention. Following this training, supportive meetings were conducted face-to-face and online. After the completion of the training, teachers went on to apply play-based pedagogy in the classrooms for approximately 2 months as a piloting phase. 

The initial synchronous online sessions indicated that some teachers were not actively participating and needed more guidance. The wide use of smartphones played a crucial role to overcome this problem. Teachers were given SIM cards of carriers with strong network coverage and internet packages to avoid disruptions during the sessions. Field managers with content team members have been assigned to ensure proper communication, accessibility and guidance is in place to encourage participation and monitor implementation. 

Based on the outcome of this piloting, the design will be modified as needed. In 2023, a larger group of teachers will participate in blended CPD to increase their skills to incorporate play-based pedagogy in classrooms.

How Aga Khan Foundation uses a decision tree to assess participants’ accessibility to technology

Considerations for accessible online learning are multi-facetted. One core aspect is learners’ accessibility to devices and bandwidth for watching instructional videos. The Aga Khan Foundation uses a simple “decision-making tree” for assessing participants’ accessibility to appropriate technology which influences how video-based learning content is disseminated. 

Not captured in the “tree”, but of importance is how the accessibility to different types of devices influences content creation. For example, data from the Aga Khan Foundation’s Learning Hub demonstrates that learners with mobile devices spend on average 5.5 minutes engaged in learning compared to those with desktops and tablets who spend over 16 and 45 minutes respectively. Producers of learning content can use such data to make decisions around dissemination strategies as well as length of learning content.

Decision tree that is used to assess participants' accessibility to technology.

Radio Professional Development for Teachers in Uganda | by STiR Education

During COVID-19, STiR Education developed an approach to leverage its expertise, capacity and networks to support the Ministry of Education and Sports to address its emergency priorities. Connectivity and technological challenges presented significant barriers to delivering this curriculum online. We aimed to broadcast 30-minute radio sessions through up to 15 different radio stations across 32 districts. Radio is one of the longest serving and most accessible education technology in Uganda. 

We launched a bi-weekly, radio-based continuous professional development programme (CPD) for teachers in 32 districts and 8 municipalities. This would involve: 

  • Production of a 30-minute lesson for all teachers across subjects and phases delivered over radio every two weeks. 
  • Use of evidence-based teaching strategies.
  • Follow up support materials for school leaders and education managers.
  • Weekly support calls to officials.
  • Bi-weekly head teacher conference calls. 
  • Share audio and printed CPD content via WhatsApp.

What worked

  • Radio lessons motivated teachers and excited them about being resilient and supporting their learners.
  • Radio built momentum and helped teachers in the subsequent return to classrooms because they had learned social emotional strategies. 
  • It promoted local ownership and support from district education officers. 
  • The shared recordings of the radio sessions helped many teachers to access the content.
  • WhatsApp learning networks were used to collect feedback from teachers, and share success stories, challenges and learnings.
  • Group phone conference calls helped continuing reflection meetings and increase resilience and coping with the pandemic.
  • Follow-up support materials to support further learning, delivered via WhatsApp.

Challenges

  • Initially, many sessions were not broadcast on the agreed date or time, which risked disengaging teachers. 
  • Access to radio sessions varied between districts. 
  • There was limited follow-up on action plans by the teachers because the schools were shut down.
  • Poor network connectivity presented challenges to our regular calls with school leaders and district officials. 

Learnings

  • We need to be flexible in our programme design and delivery to adapt to using approaches that are relevant in the context.
  • Blended use of radio, phone group coaching and WhatsApp increased the engagement of school leaders and teachers in professional development during the pandemic.
  • Actively identify and reflect upon the challenges of remote delivery in offline contexts and use the reflections to iterate and improve. 

Example of a blended initialteacher training (ITT) approach for women in rural Sierra Leone by Plan International and Open University

The Learning Assistant Programme in Sierra Leone emerged from the GATE-GEC project, funded by UK aid through the Foreign, Commonwealth and Development Office’s (FCDO) Girls’ Education Challenge. 

GATE-GEC aimed to support marginalised girls and children with disabilities in primary and junior secondary schools in Sierra Leone to attend school, reach their full learning potential, learn in a safe and inclusive environment, and successfully transition to further education and beyond. In Sierra Leone, only 27% of teachers at primary level and 14% at secondary level are female; this has immediate consequences on girls’ enrolment, retention and achievement as well as school culture, with longer-term impact on girls’ aspirations, safety in school and job prospects. 

This programme was designed to support young women, who had not previously completed their own primary education, through their professionalisation to qualify as primary school teachers. The programme was delivered through a partnership with Plan International, Open University, the Teaching Services Commission and initial teacher training providers within Sierra Leone. The project currently has 483 graduates from two cohorts; a third cohort of 228 teachers have been trained and sat their NCTVA teacher qualification exams at the end of 2021. Participants initially worked as Learning Assistants in schools within their local communities, undertaking a practical work placement and engaged in a distance learning programme (Maths and English) supported by a tutor, before sitting their entrance examinations for Initial Teacher Training Colleges (ITTCs). 

This model is not an example of blended continuous professional development per se, it is a blended model of initial teacher training. An initial work placement is accompanied by a foundational literacy and numeracy skills development programme. After passing their ITTC entrance exams, participants begin the distance model of ITT training. The model requires a combination of face-to-face mentoring and support from Programme Study Mentors who visit the teachers throughout their school-based placements, ensuring that participants are receiving appropriate support from head teachers in the school setting with access to relevant teacher training materials. 

Materials for distance learning included paper-based learning materials and the use of digital technology in the form of tablet-based teacher training modules. The tablets allow trainees to access digital content in the form of ITT modules including literacy, numeracy, child protection, safeguarding and inclusive pedagogy and others via a mobile Moodle application. This mitigates internet connectivity issues within rural areas in Sierra Leone, with content updates and maintenance accessed by the trainees periodically while visiting an area with connectivity and when attending face-to-face training. In additional to the distance learning and school-based training, trainees met for face-to face training to encourage reflective practice and enable participants to form regional communities of practice. 

The programme was adapted throughout the Covid-19 pandemic, with newly-qualified teachers trained to support vulnerable girls and children with disabilities in their localities during school closures, providing telephone-based home learning, child welfare and protection.

For further information visit the following website.

A Digital Data Ecosystem to evaluate blended CPD in Rwanda | by VVOB

Together with the University of Rwanda – College of Education (UR-CE), Rwanda Basic Education Board (REB), VVOB – education for development offers CPD programmes to educators in Rwanda. 

As part of these programmes, VVOB builds the capacity of REB and UR-CE to evaluate the CPD programmes. The evaluation system relied on standalone, paper-based instruments which limited the ability to gain access to real time data and to connect datasets. To improve the evaluation system, VVOB and partners developed a digital data ecosystem. 

The system is made up of interconnected information technology resources that allow for a fully digital process, from data collection to reporting. The digital data ecosystem has resulted in fewer errors and faster feedback loops. The system is built on a framework developed by Kirkpatrick & Kirkpatrick (2015) which states that an evaluation of a training programme (e.g. CPD programmes) should focus on four levels:

  1. Level 1 Reaction: this level focuses on the degree to which participants react favourably to the CPD. Examples of indicators are satisfaction, engagement and relevance. 
  2. Level 2 Learning: this level focuses on understanding whether the CPD has increased the knowledge and competences of participants. In addition, it is also important to evaluate commitment and confidence at this level, as these two indicators help to close the gap between learning and behaviour. 
  3. Level 3 Behaviour: this level focuses on the degree to which participants apply what they have learnt on the job. 
  4. Level 4 Results: this level looks at whether the CPD has had an impact on the overall (school) environment.Examples of indicators are improvements in the application of the five standards of school leadership and an improvement in school culture. 

In addition to these four levels, an extra level has been added: Level 0 Participation. This level studies the level of participation in the blended CPD programme. 

The digital data ecosystem is made up of components that are integrated in a dashboard that includes Key Performance Indicators for each level. The process to generate the dashboard has been digitised. Figure 19 shows the digital data ecosystem architecture, the software that has been used and how it is being applied.

How Right to Play evaluates the outcomes of the Partners in Play (P3) Project

The goal of the Partners in Play (P3) project is to improve the quality of education for Ghanaian girls and boys aged 4-12 through a scalable and replicable Learning through Play (LtP) model. 

To achieve this, improving the capacity of the Ghanaian education sector to integrate LtP to deliver the curriculum is seen as an important step. One capacity building activity in this programme is the Reading Through Play e-training course, in which the first-line beneficiaries are primary- and secondary-grade teachers.

For the monitoring, evaluation and learning component of this course, the quality of the course content and the delivery of the e-training are evaluated. This is done by measuring improvements in knowledge, attitudes and practices of participants.

The LMS platform which hosts the e-training course has an embedded reporting system that tracks reach and individual progression. In the areas where the LMS cannot evaluate a user’s behaviour and attitude, a pre- and post-survey is directly incorporated in the e-training course that must be filled out by each participant.

How VVOB in Vietnam organised a dry run to improve the CPD trajectory

In Vietnam, VVOB works in close partnership with the Ministry of Education on strengthening blended learning approaches with teachers and school leaders. Through a blended CPD trajectory that embeds play-based learning approaches, school leaders and teachers are trained to provide responsive and engaging learning experiences to their learners. 

The blended CPD trajectory starts with a Digital Literacy course to ensure that all participants have the required digital knowledge, skills, and tools. This Digital Literacy course was in-person, tailormade for this trajectory and addresses both general digital literacy as well as programme-specific content with a focus on Moodle, as this is the main course platform. The course takes 1.5 days to complete. 

As this was a newly developed course, VVOB decided to organise both a dry run and a pilot. The dry run consisted of a run of the complete course, with all the course facilitators present to go through the course with a group of learners composed of VVOB staff and focal points of the Ministry of Education and Training. At the end of the course, all participants of the dry run shared their feedback on the content of the course, the design of the activities and the facilitation methods. 

After this dry run, there were still a few uncertainties about the practical organisation of the course with many learners in one room (70-100 people), all needing access to Wi-Fi and personal support. Therefore, a pilot of two cohorts was conducted with the target group of teachers in one of the target provinces. This pilot allowed VVOB to analyse organisational challenges and find ways to solve these challenges. Both VVOB staff and the course participants shared their feedback after the pilot. The focus of the pilot was more on the organisation of the course, but feedback on content, facilitation, methods and learning outcomes was also collected. 

Both the dry run and the pilot contributed to a stronger course. Nevertheless, VVOB opted to take an iterative approach throughout the whole course cycle and kept organising feedback moments with the facilitators after every cohort to finetune the course.  

  • 1
  • 2